Well, thank you to everyone who came out Sunday night (22Nov2009) to our meet up. There were a BUNCH of great new friends made. I will be presenting more links and information real soon.
Like I said in the beginning of my (attempt at a) presentation – my relationship with Novation has always been choppy [note 1].
Right now I want to talk about the Launchpad failure. Over the night I talked with one Ableton user who had great success, I could be an isolated incident.
Regardless, I will document my travel through the Launchpad and provide my feedback and analysis of the situation. This is only my personal experience from an editorial point of view. This is, in no way, a formal endorsement or otherwise on this equipment. Just an audio geek (junkie) not having a good time…
My Equipment (as pertaining to the situation):
- White Mac Book running Ableton and not much of anything else. This particular laptop is 100% music only. And of that music, 99.9% is Ableton.
- TC Electronics Konnekt 24D Firewire Interface
- Ableton
- I am not on Snow Leopard yet.
Other Applications I am suspicious of:
Back story:
I put a Launchpad on hold on the release day (I am one of those geeks, I was at Guitar Center on May 30 10am to get my APC on release day – it was also my birthday). Like most any purchase I read the instruction manual a few times, and there really is NOT very much at all on that topic. All you get is a quick start and this support:
Before 22Nov2009 I watched about 20 YouTube videos on the unit (where I think I learned the most). YouTube is a great resource. Two of the best tricks I learned in Ableton came from others tutorials.
I freely admit that my experience with Automap was, well, none. But I don’t think this should be a major hurdle for someone who had been deep in MIDI for over a decade and is a programmer by profession.
Automap, during my experimental week changed version quickly.I do not know if this is the norm? Version 3.3 is out as I write, I was originally bleeding edge on 3.2, and I think I started on 3.0. This does not really matter because Automap is NOT compatible with the Launchpad (my bad – am I wrong?). See the image below.

Notice a lack of Launch pad support in this Novation marketing image (pulled form Novation site 23Nov2009)
So, there is not a heck of a lot of information included or available with the Launchpad. I am damn good on the APC, seriously and that unit is not a major mind-melter out of the box.
So I upgraded Ableton and my Mac (non-Snow Leopard) before starting with a week available to fix problems [note 2]. Typical wise move. I installed the drivers. I then went through about 7 hardcore lock-ups on my Mac – one after another. When I am running on a Mac I play “dumb” and generally let things install as they want unless I see something flaming wrong. I feel Mac’s are safer to play stupid with, unlike PC where you should read every dialog box.
So the install was default. I downloaded Automap, tried to get it working for quite a while before a combination of giving up and learning that Automap does not support the Launchpad.
So I dropped that line of thought.
All in all I spent just over a week on the Launchpad. A few full days and a little bit every night (check the tweets). All in all I considered the unit “normal”, or more specifically “flawed like everything else”.
Then I get brave. I installed the Ableton version on my Windows box. That is a 64bit running a current 32bit install. Everything runs great on that box (much better than Mac in my opinion). That unit is my “work” box where I program, edit, video, Ableton, you name it (this was the first Ableton Install on the unit, my Windows 7 install is fresh).
On Windows 7
Windows was running just fine for a while. Then, with no error messages or similar, the Launch pad failed to fire up at all. A few reboots, a quick uninstall and reinstall changed nothing. The Launchpad was not powering up any more (the USB bus is strong) with no changes to configuration. I figured Win7 in combination with my 32/64bit mismatch was the problem. So I moved back to the Mac.
Back on the Mac
Having concluded that Win7 was not happy on the first day I knew I was Mac only. I chugged along for about 7 more days. No problems at all. Once I got over the hump everything ran smooth. I took my notes, pushed the unit in practice performances, etcetera. I even did a little programming in Ableton and generally had good success.
I left my Mac on over night once to make sure everything was still okay the next day, that passed just fine.
Moving on I built MIDI demos, learned how to do what the promo video outlined (watch the video). I was able to get all of this done over the course of a few nights.
The Saturday before the Meet Up I had a good 5+ hour session refining my set and trimming out fat so I could fast load a new set while holding the crowd. Smart huh?
The Sunday (before the Meetup) I spent the afternoon practicing and refining my notes. I went over my presentation practicing. All was running fine. Having performed live for well over a decade I always go over my gear carefully before a gig. Event when I was playing out several times every week. I am very much a boyscout (be prepared) at gigs. I usually have 2+ levels of redundancy allowing gear to fail (not with laptops though). Additionally, as my band mates know, I usually have extra cables and plugs as well as other goodies to help out.
So I pack up and go to the meet up. All was fine with the pre 7pm check. This remained the truth until I did the presentation.
When I picked up the Launchpad to show the kind audience (like I was doing in my preparation work) I *think* the USB cable moved a little. From there all hell broke loose.
My TC Electronics was getting kicked offline (outside of Ableton) at first. Something that NEVER happens. It was a first. Then the Launchpad was either not powering up via USB or working for one button push, or in other words it booted and once a button was pushed it seizes (with LEDS on).
I also lost MIDI out on my TC Electronics as well as 2/4 audio outputs. I reviewed my set up and all is normal. No changes, with Automap off I am recovering form the damage.
Mike (thank you) then took the unit and downloaded the drivers and could not get the unit to work.
So, at this time, through public embarrassment, I deem the Launchpad a NO GO. The data bleeds on note data,the several admissions from Novation-Land of tricky areas (no, plain old broken items), and a long laundry list of things that were almost working I formally have to declare my experience BAD. Very bad.
The unit no longer powers up. Nothing, dead, 1 week, probably 30 hours of use. OUCH!
So, for those of you looking to get a Launchpad I advise against it. Save up twice the chedder and get an APC40 or a OHM controller, or similar.
I was going to outline all the funkiness that I have in my notes, but that is not going to happen. My list was long. I was looking forward to putting a smile on a new product that has a few bugs and welcoming another controller to the world of Ableton. Those notes, photos, and other information will now rot on my drive. I wish to spend NO MORE time on this unit. Period.
Now what? Looking at getting an Akai MPD24 for my second / Max4Live controller.
[note 1] – The build quality has steadily been declining in my opinion since my first Novation products in the late 1990’s. Most recently was a XIOSynth where they keys were built incorrect and would stick “down”. 100%, beyond any reasonable doubt, bad engineering. But I did love the Bass Station back in the day.
[note 2] – My rule of thumb is to have a week available on your computer for any major upgrades and / or changes. Do not upgrade right before the gig.